CARO 2020 Clause 3(i) Explained: What Auditors Report on Fixed Assets

Simple Asset Tracker Team · · 6 min read

CARO 2020 clause 3(i) is the part of the auditor's report that deals with fixed assets. Its five sub-clauses ask the auditor to state whether the company keeps proper records of its property, plant and equipment and intangible assets, whether management physically verified the assets and properly accounted for any material discrepancies, whether title deeds are in the company's name, whether assets were revalued, and whether any benami property proceedings are pending. Below we check whether CARO applies to you at all, take each sub-clause in turn, and say what auditors usually want to see.

Who the CARO 2020 fixed assets clause applies to

The Companies (Auditor's Report) Order, 2020 was issued by the Ministry of Corporate Affairs under section 143(11) of the Companies Act, 2013. It adds matters to the statutory auditor's report on the standalone financial statements of the companies it covers, for financial years beginning on or after 1 April 2021.

It doesn't cover every company. Paragraph 1(2) of the Order excludes:

A small company under section 2(85) is a private company within the paid-up capital and turnover limits prescribed under that section. Those limits have been revised several times; since 1 December 2025 they are ₹10 crore and ₹100 crore. Holding companies, subsidiary companies, section 8 companies and companies governed by a special Act can't be small companies however small they are, so check both the definition and the current limits before deciding CARO doesn't apply to you. The Order also doesn't apply to the auditor's report on consolidated financial statements, apart from clause 3(xxi).

Clause 3(i)(a) and proper records

The auditor states whether the company is maintaining proper records showing full particulars, including quantitative details and situation, of property, plant and equipment, or PPE (sub-clause (A)), and proper records showing full particulars of intangible assets (sub-clause (B)).

The Order doesn't define "proper records". ICAI's Guidance Note on CARO 2020 lists what the records should generally contain. To identify the asset: a description good enough to identify it, the head it's classified under in the accounts, its situation and its quantity. For the numbers: original cost, year of purchase, date put to use, useful life, residual value, component-wise breakup where applicable, revaluation details, the rate or basis of depreciation, depreciation for the year, accumulated depreciation, impairment, and particulars of sale or discarding. The Guidance Note also says the totals in these records should reconcile with the books of account, and that no single format is prescribed.

In practice that's a fixed asset register kept up to date, with a location against every asset and quantities that match what's on the floor, and checked by physical verification often enough to stay that way. A register that only finance can read, with "Head Office" as the location for four hundred assets, is the kind of thing that turns this sub-clause into a long conversation.

Intangible assets get forgotten more often. Software licences, trademarks and capitalised development costs need records too, with enough detail that someone can identify each one and tie it back to the figures in the accounts.

Clause 3(i)(b) and physical verification

This is the sub-clause most people have in mind when they talk about the CARO 2020 fixed assets clause. The auditor states whether the PPE has been physically verified by management at reasonable intervals, whether any material discrepancies were noticed on that verification, and, if so, whether they have been properly dealt with in the books of account.

The Guidance Note fills in what the Order leaves open:

We'd treat three years as an outer limit rather than a target. Laptops and other portable equipment move far more often than buildings or plant, so it usually makes sense to count them every year even if the rest of the register is phased.

So what an auditor typically asks for is proof of how the count was run: a written plan, instructions to the people counting, their results asset by asset, and a record of how each discrepancy was investigated and treated in the books. We walk through running the count itself in how to do physical verification of fixed assets.

Clause 3(i)(c) and title deeds

The auditor states whether the title deeds of all immovable properties disclosed in the financial statements are held in the company's name. Properties where the company is the lessee and the lease agreement is duly executed in its favour are excluded. Where a deed isn't in the company's name, the Order requires details in a set format: description of the property, gross carrying value, the name it's held in, whether that person is a promoter, director, a relative of either, or an employee, the period it's been held, and the reason it isn't in the company's name, including whether it's in dispute.

The working document here is a simple list of every property on the balance sheet with the deed reference and the name on it. Collecting it takes longer than it should when the deeds sit in different offices, so do it before the audit, not during it.

Clause 3(i)(d) and revaluation

If the company has revalued its PPE (including right-of-use assets) or intangible assets during the year, the auditor states whether the revaluation is based on a valuation by a Registered Valuer, and specifies the amount of change where it is 10% or more of the aggregate net carrying value of each class. Companies that haven't revalued during the year will see a one-line answer here. Those that do need the valuer's report and a working that shows the change by class.

Clause 3(i)(e) and benami property

The auditor states whether any proceedings have been initiated or are pending against the company for holding benami property under the Benami Transactions (Prohibition) Act, 1988 and its rules, and if so, whether the company has appropriately disclosed the details in its financial statements. (Since 2016 the Act has been called the Prohibition of Benami Property Transactions Act, 1988.) This is usually answered from the company's records of legal proceedings and management's written representations rather than from the asset register.

What to have ready

Clause 3(i) doesn't prescribe a format for any of these records, but each sub-clause is easier to answer when the evidence already exists, and the list is fairly short:

  1. A fixed asset register with the particulars above, reconciled to the books.
  2. The physical verification plan, the instructions given to the people who counted, their results, and the discrepancy log showing what was done about each item.
  3. A list of immovable properties with deed details and the name each is held in.

Add any valuation reports and a note of legal proceedings relating to property, if they apply.

The second item is where paper processes struggle most, because the evidence is spread across printouts, spreadsheets and emails. We compared the two approaches in paper vs digital physical verification.

Simple Asset Tracker keeps the results side of that trail in one place. Each verification event records which assets were assigned to which verifier, and every result carries who submitted it, when, whether the asset was scanned or picked from a list, any notes and, for a misplaced asset, where it was found. Edits to an asset's details are logged with the before and after values, and the event's results export to Excel for the audit file. If you'd like to see it on your own register, download it free for up to 30 assets.

Try it on your own assets

Simple Asset Tracker runs on your own computer or server. Import your register, print QR asset tags and run a verification from any phone. It's free for up to 30 assets.